June15 , 2026

    Which ‘Every Year After’ Stars Are — And Aren’t — Returning for Season 2 After Surprise Book Changes?

    Related

    Share


    Every Year After has plans for more seasons — with different leads — but is everyone from the cast coming back for a potential season 2?

    Based on Every Summer After by Carley Fortune, Every Year After follows Percy (Sadie Soverall), who grew up vacationing in Barry’s Bay and spending all her time with the Florek brothers: Sam (Matt Cornett) and Charlie (Michael Bradway).

    In addition to introducing new characters, Every Year After surprised Us with some massive book shakeups.

    “I think there’s less of things changing and more of things just being added. But I think you’re getting the actual bones of the book and the love story. I think all of the themes and the tone are the same,” Aurora Perrineau, who plays Percy’s friend Chantal in the series, exclusively told Us Weekly.


    Related: Meet the Star-Studded Cast of Prime Video’s ‘Every Year After’

    Fans of Off Campus and The Summer I Turned Pretty should be tuning into Prime Video’s Every Year After — but where will they recognize the cast from? Based on Every Summer After by Carley Fortune, Every Year After follows Percy (Sadie Soverall), who grew up vacationing in Barry’s Bay. After spending all her time […]

    The book also wrapped up everyone’s story more while the show focused on introducing Charlie as the next lead.

    “I really would love to see a second season of the show. They’re not quite there yet and I think because Sam is still kind of getting his head around what’s happened, that makes a lot of sense,” Fortune told Us of the ending. “I love how the show ends with a very clear set up for bringing One Golden Summer into the second season, which I’m most excited about.”

    Scroll down to see who is — and isn’t — expected to return in season 2:

    Sadie Soverall

    While Soverall is expected to reprise her role as Percy, she would no longer be front and center on the show.

    Matt Cornett

    The same goes for Cornett, who would be back as Sam but not as the main character.

    Michael Bradway

    Bradway has been positioned as the season 2 lead after Charlie’s onscreen heart attack. His story was originally explored more in Fortune’s follow-up novel, One Golden Summer.

    Who Is Every Year After’s Alice Everly? Charlie's Cliffhanger Explained


    Related: Who Is Every Year After’s Alice? [Spoiler]’s Finale Cliffhanger Explained

    Every Year After ended with a massive change — and shocking cliffhanger — but how is book character Alice Everly related to the twist? Warning: Spoilers below for season 1 of Every Year After. The Prime Video series, which premiered on Wednesday, June 10, concluded with Charlie (Michael Bradway) being estranged from brother Sam (Matt […]

    Abigail Cowen

    Cowen’s role as Delilah was expanded — and with plans for the show to have five seasons — there is more than enough room for her in season 2.

    Aurora Perrineau

    Perrineau’s Chantel is expected back on the show.

    Joseph Chiu

    As is Chiu a.k.a Jordie, who is now caught in his own love triangle.



    Source link